Motor finance firms need to stay ready as legal challenge moves to February

October 14, 2026

The FCA has confirmed that the Upper Tribunal will hear legal challenges to its motor finance compensation scheme from 16 February to 3 March 2027, with judgment expected in the following months.

The FCA has told firms to plan for the possibility that the scheme, or parts of it, could be quashed. In that situation, lenders would need to be operationally and financially ready to deal with complaints through the usual complaint-handling process and within the usual statutory timescales.

What is the latest FCA update on motor finance redress?

The FCA confirmed on the 13th October 2026 that the Upper Tribunal will hear the legal challenges to its motor finance compensation scheme between 16 February to 3 March 2027.

The challenges come from Volkswagen Financial Services, Mercedes Benz Financial Services and Crédit Agricole Auto Finance, alongside a separate challenge from Consumer Voice, represented by Courmacs Legal. While the legal process continues, the scheme remains partially suspended. Lenders do not currently need to calculate or pay compensation, but they must continue to comply with the rules that remain in force.

What does the February 2027 hearing mean for motor finance operations?

The hearing gives firms more certainty over the timing of the next stage, but not the process they may eventually need to deliver. The FCA has told lenders to prepare for the possibility that the scheme, or parts of it, could be quashed. If this happens, there may be no motor finance compensation scheme and no pause in complaint handling. Complaints could instead need to be resolved through the usual process and within the usual statutory timescales. That means firms need to prepare for more than one possible operating model while the legal challenge continues.

What still needs to happen while the scheme is partially suspended?

A partial suspension does not mean work stops. The FCA says firms must continue identifying relevant complaints and agreements and gathering the data needed to identify commission arrangements and disclosure practices. It also covers certain consumer responses, broker information requests and cooperation with the Financial Ombudsman Service.

Firms also need to keep complainants updated on the legal challenge, what the partial suspension means and how it could affect the timetable for dealing with their complaint or paying compensation.

What are the operational risks for motor finance firms?

The main difficulty is preparing teams and processes when the eventual route for resolving complaints is not yet settled. The FCA expects lenders to be operationally and financially ready if they have to handle complaints individually rather than through the compensation scheme. It has also said firms should notify it at the earliest opportunity of problems that could materially affect their operational or financial resilience or their ability to carry out scheme steps.

Firms therefore need a realistic view of the people, processes and operational capacity they would have available under either scenario.

What should firms be doing ahead of the February 2027 hearing?

Preparation should continue against the requirements that remain in force. For operations leaders, that includes understanding the work already in the pipeline, how readily the required information can be accessed and where additional resources may be needed if complaint-handling activity increases. 

The regulator has asked firms to plan rigorously for the possibility that the scheme does not proceed as currently envisaged. Therefore, waiting until the Tribunal process concludes could leave little room to increase capacity or adjust delivery models if requirements change quickly. 

What could happen after the motor finance legal challenge?

The hearing itself may not provide an immediate answer. The FCA expects judgment in the months following the February hearing. If the scheme is upheld, firms will need to be ready to meet its requirements. If it is overturned in whole or in part, the FCA has said it could instead require lenders to resolve complaints individually through the usual complaints process.

When will the motor finance legal challenge be heard?

The Upper Tribunal hearing is scheduled for the 16th to the 26th February 2027, with judgment expected in the following months.

Do motor finance firms still need to prepare for the proposed motor finance compensation and redress scheme?

Yes. Firms must continue preparing for the scheme, progress complaints as far as possible and comply with the rules that have not been suspended.

Could motor finance complaints return to normal complaint handling?

Yes. The FCA has told lenders to plan for a scenario where the scheme, or parts of it, are quashed and complaints need to be resolved through the usual complaint-handling process and statutory timescales.

Motor finance firms need enough operational flexibility to respond as the legal position develops.

Momenta can provide experienced complaints and remediation resources to help firms increase operational capacity when needed, whether that means supporting existing teams or mobilising larger-scale delivery programmes.

Talk to our team about your motor finance resourcing and operational requirements.

Latest

Australia Momenta

An Australian MLRO for an overseas business: when does fractional make sense?

November 6, 2026
Wholesale bank

What do the FCA’s 2026 supervision insights mean for wholesale banking teams?

November 5, 2026
Motor finance MOM

Motor finance settlement offers put delivery readiness in focus

November 3, 2026

Subscribe for updates

Receive regular insights including industry leader interviews, blogs and key trends